Is Nonsensical Language More Sophisticated?
Updated: Nov 12
This is a question I have been pondering as a result of revisiting an interview I recorded (several years back) with linguist, Lisa Smartt in my YouTube series. In her book, Words at the Threshold, she shares her observations regarding the changing language that often surfaces when people are nearing the end of their physical lives. The title of this blog refers to a perspective she proposed in our conversation. Lisa suggested that metaphoric and nonsensical language break apart known patterns of words, in turn inviting us to listen and open to experience the world from a different point of view.
In the foundational years of my hospice work I read a book titled Final Gifts that was life changing. Maggie Callanan and Patricia Kelley (two hospice nurses) are the authors. They too spoke of the changing language. Though sometimes uncomfortable to engage in, they encourage us to lean in and pay attention instead of discounting the communication. That listening to the varying language of the actively dying may be a gateway into a broader, ineffable realm of discovery. The deeper mystery of life itself.
It was not until my interview with Lisa, when she referred to Dr. Raymond Moody, that I learned he was not only an MD but had a PhD in philosophy. He had done his doctorate on unintelligible and nonsensical language before his work on near death experiences (a term he later coined). It was due to this research, stirring a different curiosity within, that allowed Raymond to begin noticing the patterns in what people were describing after being resuscitated due to cardiac arrest or other life-threatening situations. While most medical staff were ignoring the patient’s language or quietly discounting it to be unimportant, he leaned in and began documenting the repetitive patterns of what they were claiming to have experienced before becoming conscious again. This led to his foundational, groundbreaking research on near death experiences.
On the one hand giving something a definition can be so helpful, to allow energy and attention to become laser focused and result in distinct outcomes. Yet, what if language when held too literally, can impose on our ability to see a larger picture? Limiting our exploration of broader states of awareness or possibilities?
How would the approach Lisa offers also change our engagement with Alzheimer's patients? With those who are neuro diverse and experience language in different ways? Could a change in perspective provide greater connection when engaging with curiosity and wonder? Being a little more courageous to simply flow with the words spoken in their organic form and see what new insights are discovered? Or invite new ways to connect and communicate with those who are non-verbal?
In this time of heighten emphasis on literal and linear approaches to life, my interview with linguist, Lisa Smartt invites a somewhat refreshing, different point of view which I find stimulating in so many ways. At one point she even refers to the wisdom of Dr. Seuss! Once again, I invite you to view our conversation through the link to my YouTube series titled “Inspiring, Heartfelt Conversations”: https://youtu.be/TJ45kUgmEdg
As the advancement of new technology continues to emerge, my curiosity deepens as to ways to maintain the artful dance of bringing intentional structure and creative flow into greater harmony. To honour the mystery and full scope of life.
Photo courtesy of Joyce Hankins from Unsplash free photos






























Comments